/ Technology

We test the iPhone 4 – it’s got a dodgy proximity sensor

Another day, another iPhone 4 problem in the headlines. But that’s the price Apple pays for launching a must-have phone that has eager punters queuing around the block just to get close to one.

And now those people have got up close and personal with the iPhone 4, they’ve found it’s playing up and developing a mind of its own. Users have complained about unintentionally switching on Apple’s FaceTime video-conferencing and accidental call making.

It’s all down to the proximity sensor, a bit of electronic wizardry that most of us probably aren’t aware of. Instead, we all continue happily in the assumption that when we place our ear close to a touchscreen phone, its screen will magically turn off, and our auricular orifice won’t be responsible for doing the dialling normally performed by our digits.

As with all Apple issues, this one’s all over the web, from the thousands of comments on the Apple support forum, to plenty of YouTube videos alleging to demonstrate the issue.

iPhone 4 vs iPhone 3GS in the labs

But nothing beats a bit of science to confirm (or quash) a rumour, so Which? sent a shiny new iPhone 4 off to its labs for an expert verdict.

Our results showed that the iPhone 3GS deactivated on-screen buttons when we were 55mm from its surface, with the iPhone 4 doing the same at just 40mm – a difference of almost 30%.

We also found that the iPhone 4 took about half-a-second longer than the 3GS to deactivate the screen when it reached its activation range. Remarkable given that Apple has had three previous attempts at making phones that work.

What’s the deal Apple?

Apple has yet to respond to this criticism of its latest iPhone, but some users believe there’s an easy fix – reset your iPhone 4 network settings. Or you could try the advice of an Apple ‘genius’ who claims your ears are at fault… for being too clean.

How Apple will deal with the discord surrounding the iPhone 4’s many problems is currently unknown. But Which? recommends that if it can be fixed with a software update, Apple might be wise to release that very, very soon. There must be a limit to the patience of the millions of gadget lovers who have paid hundreds of pounds for their treasured iPhone 4.


How many more issues will the iPhone ‘4’ have? It’s actually the iPhone 2.1 and it’s pretty clear that you shouldn’t buy the first iteration of an Apple phone. Wait until 2.2 or 2.3 for them to iron everything out.

So Apple has just announced that they will be tackling the iPhone 4's proximity sensor issues in a software update in the near future.

Isn't it an example of a problem with the beta version that buyers should find out all the problems and let Apple know ? Surely no one would buy a new car on the day it was announced because problems need to be ironed out. Wait a few months and then buy.
Just image the uproar if it had been produced by Microsoft and their record !

The beta phase should be a testing phase. Beta's should be done either behind doors or among a select group of test people.

Microsoft's Xbox 360 had a 30% failure rate (ie. it broke) and was clearly rushed to market with little testing – there should have been a bigger uproar about that. At least the iPhone 4 isn't breaking…fingers crossed.

Why do people keep rushing for the newest versions of 'tech'; time after time we find a later update has ironed out the bugs and is far better – just wait a few months!!

A new iPhone software bug has emerged, where thieves can make calls, listen to your voicemails etc. without having to enter a pass-code. It effects phones with the latest iOS 4.1 software. The next software update, iOS 4.2 should fix the problem, but that’s not due for another month.

Does this bug worry you? I still own a phone where you all you need to do is press two buttons to unlock it… so I can’t see the fuss really.

What has happend to the English you are all test dummies