/ Technology

Your view: O2’s mid-contract price hike

O2 and Fixed Means Fixed

O2 is increasing prices for new and existing customers alike. An RPI price rise of 2.7% on pay-monthly contracts will hit customers in March 2014. Here’s a round-up of O2 customers’ views on the hike.

David can’t understand the logic for O2’s latest price rise:

‘I cannot fathom how a company can think this behaviour is appropriate. How can it be possible to decide unilaterally to raise the rate on a fixed price deal? This was my first contract phone; it’ll likely be my last with O2.’

David isn’t the only customer pledging to leave O2. Eric is also turning his back on them:

‘I am an O2 customer with two monthly contracts. They may make £6 with the 2.7% rise, but instead of staying loyal, I’m off. They can shove their £76-ish contracts where the sun don’t shine. Their loss in the long run, and every O2 customer should do likewise and write to the CEO.’

Mandy isn’t buying O2’s reasons for hiking prices:

‘What’s worse is that part of the explanation on their website talks about their costs relating to expanding their 4G network when I’m on a contract on a phone that doesn’t even work on 4G so I’m not exactly sure why I should be pleased that this is how they’re investing my money!’

Peter’s whole family has said goodbye to O2:

‘Unbelievable arrogance of big business. “We are upping your charges. Just because we can. No you can’t leave. Not without a large penalty.” My family will never go with O2 again, and I’ll be advising colleagues and friends to do same.’

And Grant has decided to pay off his whole contract to be rid of the company:

‘I’ve just got the same text, called them, paid £231 to pay my contract up and they can loose a customer as there so intent on making an extra 99p they can loose £40 per month…they don’t care about their customers from the attitude of the advisor I spoke to!’

Finally, Mike gets our Comment of the Week for explaining why fixed should mean fixed:

‘People try to budget by taking out contracts, and so should mobile companies in setting their prices of the term of a contract. If they need to change their prices once a year then they should stop offering two year contracts.’

If you’re unhappy about O2’s price rise for new customers, email O2’s CEO to make him think again. Are you an O2 customer? What do you think of the mobile company’s latest mid-contract price rise?

Comments
Guest
Andrew says:
31 January 2014

I don’t actually have a problem with prices going up, when it is justified, and I don’t mind if they adjust prices annually. But when I’ve only been with the toads of O2 for six weeks, I don’t expect them to up their costs by an arbitrary figure that relates to the change in a basket of consumer goods over the previous year.

That for me is the problem. I didn’t believe that my price was fixed (you usually have to pay extra for that in any other market, say energy or mortgages), but I had foolishly assumed that the price rises would be for changes during the term of my contract, in which case I’d expect a single RPI change at the mid point of a two year contract.

So what I’m going to do is formally complain to O2, ask them to rescind the price increases because this is a new contract, and RPI has barely changed since it was taken out. I know they’ll refuse, but I shall then ask for a deadlock letter, and eventually refer it to the Communications Ombusdman. The reason for doing this is not because I expect to get much joy, but because if they won’t issue a deadlock letter I can complaint to OFCOM that O2 are breaching the conditions of their licence (this is a very serious matter), and if they do, then a referral to the Ombudsman costs them money. If they pay by referred case then this will be several hundred pounds, and it will cost O2 about £100 in staff time defending the complaint.

I’d encourage all unhappy (newish) customers to do likewise. Older customers may be on a hiding to nothing unless they can prove that the contract was described as fixed price, but there may be opportunity to complain about things like overseas calls and MMS costs, where they’ve put the costs up by far more than RPI.

Guest
Tates says:
2 February 2014

I am following the same approach. My two year O2 contract is less than 6 weeks old. So they should have known about the increase and should have informed me before I signed the contract. It will be interesting to see what will happen when eventually it gets to OFCOM. For me any increase in the first year is abusive to consumers.

Guest

I have emailed o2 as follows

Dear Mr Lawton, General Manger – Business

I received a letter on 29/01/2014 telling me that you intend to increase the mobile phone charges in March 2014.

I signed up to a fixed term contract, which you are now trying to change. After researching the legality of this action, I would like to make the following points

1. Ofcom regulations clearly state that the only price rises allowed on a fixed term contract are those relating to tax rises. I refer you to http://media.ofcom.org.uk/2013/10/23/protection-for-consumers-against-mid-contract-price-rises/ Therefore a rise in line with the retail price index (as quoted in your letter) should not occur .

2. The only customers that you can enforce price increases on according to the “Which” report, are new customer who joined o2 after the implementation of Ofcom regulations, on the 23/01/2014 providing that the sales representative made it clear that a price increase could be implemented during the length of the fixed term. (please see link below.) I am clearly not a new customer. When I telephoned to question the price rise your representative was unable to read out any relevant part of the terms and conditions relating to the price rise. I repeatedly asked to speak to a supervisor or manager who could explain why your company is not complying with the Ofcom regulation to set out clear terms and conditions with regard to price increases within a fixed term contract. I was repeatedly told that this is company policy and I could speak to nobody else.

http://view.mail.which.co.uk/?j=fec917747562037f&m=fe9e137075650c7c75&ls=fe2c15727c660c75741474&l=ff5b127772&s=fe7017717561007d7415&jb=ff9d1571&ju=fe56157174630c7a7d1c&utm_medium=Email&utm_source=ExactTarget&utm_campaign=fixed_means_fixed_23012014&r=0

Below is a direct quote from the Ofcom regulations, as mentioned in my first point above.

This Guidance sets out that:
• Ofcom is likely to regard any increase3 to the recurring monthly subscription charge4 in a fixed-term contract as ‘materially detrimental’ to consumers;
• providers should therefore give consumers at least 30 days’ notice of any such price rise and allow them to exit their contract without penalty; and
• any changes to contract terms, pricing or otherwise, must be communicated clearly and transparently to consumers.
In accordance with the three bullet points above I have the right to exit my current contract without penalty.

I look forward to hearing from you shortly so that this matter can be resolved.

Maurice M

and have received an automated reply saying there will reply within days ?

Thanks for your email. We’ll look into things and get back to you as soon as we can. At the moment, that should be within 7 working days.

If you’d rather talk to us sooner, our Complaints Support Team are ready to web chat to you.

Just click the button below to start.

Description: Description: Description: Description: Description: cid:image001.jpg@01CD5455.4ADF3D70

They’re available every day, 8.30am till 10pm.

You can see all the details of our complaints process at http://www.o2.co.uk/complaints.

My contract has 2 months to run guess I won’t be returning to o2

I’m a self employed heating engineer and I can just hear myself trying to explain to my customers that the price I quoted was in fact not a true price and had a hidden clause in the terms and conditions that allows me to increase the QUOTED price by RPI at the time of installation. I wonder how long I would be in business

Guest

I got my reply today as follows

Thanks for your email.

I’m sorry you’re unhappy with the announcement about our price change. This is in line with the Retail Price Index (RPI) inflation rate that was announced on 14 January 2014.

As we said in the announcement, we want to give customers the best possible service, for the best possible value. With the current Retail Price Index (RPI) rate of inflation at 2.7%, the cost of everything is going up. As a result, we’re adjusting the price of Pay Monthly Tariffs in line with RPI.

We’re completely modernising our entire network and investing £1.5m every day on replacing and upgrading equipment to ensure our 2G and 3G networks continue to deliver the best experience for our customers. In just 5 months our 4G network is live in 13 cities and over 120 surrounding towns giving access to over 18 million people in the UK, that’s 30% of the UK population. In the last year, we’ve also launched O2 Refresh and we continue to offer extras such as O2 Priority Moments, O2 Gurus, O2 Wifi and O2 Recycle.

A price rise is never welcome but it is covered in your Pay Monthly Mobile Agreement, which comply with applicable law and regulation. Ofcom’s recent “fixed means fixed” guidance applies only to new contracts made after 23rd January 2014 and the terms and conditions you agreed to when you signed up stated that we are entitled to increase your monthly subscription charge by no more than RPI and no more often than every 12 months. These terms are compliant with the body of general consumer protection law. Our advertising has also said ‘tariff prices may go up’ since January 2013.

An increase of this kind does not entitle you to end your airtime agreement mid-contract without paying the remaining months of your subscription. You’ll see the price increase from your March 2014 bill. There’s more information about this on our website: http://www.o2.co.uk/prices.

We trust this provides you with an adequate explanation our decision.

Kind regards

Guest

Complaint Review Service
A few points that you have failed to grasp
I have been a customer since March 2010 I renewed my contract in March 2012 so your reply stating “Our advertising has also said ‘tariff prices may go up’ since January 2013.” Is irrelevant
Do you think for one minute I’m in the slightest bit interested in your future plans to improve this service?
We’re completely modernising our entire network and investing £1.5m every day on replacing and upgrading equipment to ensure our 2G and 3G networks continue to deliver the best experience for our customers. In just 5 months our 4G network is live in 13 cities and over 120 surrounding towns giving access to over 18 million people in the UK, that’s 30% of the UK population. In the last year, we’ve also launched O2 Refresh and we continue to offer extras such as O2 Priority Moments, O2 Gurus, O2 Wifi and O2 Recycle.
If your company can not put enough monies aside for future upgrades or improvements from the profits you are already making you really need to speak to your R+D department about planning.
Ofcom regulations came into force on the 24th January as far as I can see those regulations do not give you the right to change any part of our contract in fact the regulation are designed to do the exact opposite
I again quote
This Guidance sets out that:
• Ofcom is likely to regard any increase3 to the recurring monthly subscription charge4 in a fixed-term contract as ‘materially detrimental’ to consumers;
• providers should therefore give consumers at least 30 days’ notice of any such price rise and allow them to exit their contract without penalty; and
• any changes to contract terms, pricing or otherwise, must be communicated clearly and transparently to consumers.
In accordance with the three bullet points above I have the right to exit my current contract without penalty.

I look forward to hearing from you shortly so that this matter can be resolved.

Maurice M

Guest

they replied the next day with Hi Maurice
We’re sorry you remain unhappy. Price increases are never welcome but inflation has an impact on our costs. We will continue to invest in the network and the services that matter to our customers. We hope we’ve clearly explained the reasons for this decision.
As your contracted started before the 23 January 2014, it allows us to apply a yearly price rise by no more than RPI. This part of the contract, stating that prices can increase, was set out both in your contract and in your summary terms.
This is our final position on the matter. Unfortunately, your complaint about the price rise does not fall within the independent Ombudsman’s remit. But if you have any other concerns that you feel we have not been able to resolve for you, or you wish to clarify the Ombudsman’s position, you can contact them on the details below for further advice:

Guest

My reply to them

Once again you have failed to address my concerns

I have been a customer since March 2010 I renewed my contract in March 2012 so your reply stating “Our advertising has also said “tariff prices may go up’ since January 2013.” Is irrelevant

“As your contracted started before the 23 January 2014, it allows us to apply a yearly price rise by no more than RPI. This part of the contract, stating that prices can increase, was set out both in your contract and in your summary terms.”

Can you supply me with a copy of the contract that I agreed to in March 2012 in particular the clause that states you have the right to increase prices by RPI.

Can you also supply me with the OFCOM regulation that states you have the right to increase a fixed terms contract by any amount other than those increases which are caused by increases in tax.

As the this increase falls after the date that the OFCOM regulations came in to force I have the right to expect o2 Telefónica UK Limited to comply with the regulations.

It appears that the company you represent has no intentions of complying with OFCOM regulations!

So you leave me with no alterative but to ask you to supply my PAC on the 10th of March 2014 as I will be leaving o2 never to return on the 10th April 2014 (at the end of my contract).

Maurice M

Guest
Ian says:
4 June 2014

I’d be interested to hear if O2 did try to resolve this complaint or if they just sent a PAC code.

Guest

I have also noted that o2’s new terms and conditions have changed significantly Guess what clause 1 is………………………………….. yes you got it right allowing o2 the right to increase prices by RPI

Question 1 is this an admission that they previous T&C where in fact misleading or just written in such a way to cause misunderstandings ,, please pass the magnifying glass

Guest

Why do people still use O2? If they want to benefit from O2’s excellent coverage, they should be customers of Giffgaff, O2’s sister company. Both O2 and Giffgaff are owned by Telefonica and use O2’s network. Giffgaff doesn’t increase its prices.

Guest

o2 HAVE excellent coverage !! (Heavy sarcasm) i have during my 5 years with o2 found that there are large areas o2 do not cover the North West of England to name one parts of the South East huge chunks of the M6 and A1 between these two have to say the least iffy coverage. The whole of the Lake District is an o2 free zone.

Guest

You will not find any network that offers coverage of all areas. I have never had a phone on the O2 network but have often had to borrow one when on holiday, when in rural areas where only O2 would work.

If there is no signal, emergency calls can be routed via a different network. Hopefully the companies will work out that this is a good way of working together and improving coverage for all mobile phone users.

Guest
Janet officer says:
1 February 2014

I also have 2 contracts with o2 and this is the 2nd time they’ve increased one if them. I’ve been with 02 for about 13 years but I’m already shopping around as I will not be renewing either contract. I’m done with o2 for good now.

Guest
Diane says:
2 February 2014

I’ve been with O2 for 6 months and am furious at their cheek selling a fixed price contract when it isn’t. They may have found a loophole but under the Sales Acts I believe I was mis-sold this product as I was not told at any time when I was consulting O2 for the right deal that the fixed price could change. I would not have started my contract if I’d known they could raise the fixed price. Is this a feasible argument to pursue?

Guest
Hilary says:
3 February 2014

I renewed my contract with O2 & within 10 days the price has gone up. They must have known before contract started bot omitted to tell me! In all other instances a contract is a contract & neither party should break it!

Guest

You have the right in law to change your mind for 14 days I would advise you you to exercise your right to cancel

Guest
welleezee says:
3 February 2014

I’ve been with 02 for many years and until recently did not have a complaint as once the contract price was agreed that was it. But of course we in the UK are now treated as cash cows by foreign owned companies from energy to water to mobile phones. You can believe it that once the contract ends I will be changing my provider only one more year to go…

Guest

My contract is up at the end of February and as I was stung with a price rise earlier I am moving my phone over to Tesco and getting a better deal I suggest others do as I did and move when you can … Vote with your feet as they say.

Guest

I can’t believe that which is not on to ofcom asking for clarification of the ofcom regs with regrade to what O2 are saying

Guest
waveylines says:
16 February 2014

I have just joined O2 -and yes they have had the audacity to put their prices up within two weeks of joining them -leave you tell me! however i have just left EE because they decided to take the masks down and rendered me with no signal in my area ( in the middle of a city) and didn’t tell me this was the problem for 6 months.
Ofcom did not seem bothered that EE had effectively with drawn their service from me half way through my contract and were still able to charge me! Am still in the middle of a big battle to get money out of them -so far -i have had about half of what they really owe me. the thought of taking on O2 as well makes me feel ill -but I will –

I think Ofcom need to consider that fact that a price hike within two weeks without being told this would happen is tantamount to mis-selling. Even gas and electricity don’t do this if you take out a fixed term -If they do give you price increase you normally have the right to move else where….so how come Mobile phone company’s think they are different?

You know these companies need a proper shake up by a regulatory body that has teeth -it seems the current ones have none!!! So if I leave O2 there isn’t another mobile phone company that still delivers signal to my house -so my option would be to have pay as you go -so that I just pay for what i actually can get as a service. maybe this is what we all should do! that would give them a massive jolt – without us they will no longer exist….so keep your landlines -at least you get a reliable service and no drop out!!!!!

Guest

I just terminated my account with O2 – I have reached the end of my contract and did not wish to continue with them on principle because of the unexpected price hikes.

Unbelievably, when I spoke to them to get my PAC code the service representative told me it wasn’t down to O2, it was the government that set the RPI level and they had to follow it!! She was quite insistent it was down to the government….!!

She also said that every other operator does it (why does that make it right??) – when I asked about Tesco, she initially said that they did & when I suggested that was a lie she then said that they will be doing so shortly. I think that is just misleading.

What started as a matter of fact conversation left me seething. Unbelievable arrogance.

Guest
Kenny says:
2 March 2014

I’ve read all the comments and I’m very annoyed with the price hikes too. Certainly OFCOM should have the power to force O2 to accept its findings. What is the point of having a regulatory body it can’t force the companies it regulates to accept its findings. My wife and I both have contracts with O2 and I will be advising her to look else where as hers expires in May and I will be doing the same when mines up in August. From my understanding this new rule that O2 has been using should apply to new customers and not the old ones but as always British consumers gets no protection.

Guest

Now EE have sent a letter informing about 2.7% price increase (apparently in line with inflation) from 28th May. Only applies to contracts before Ofcom ruling (23 Jan). My second increase on a fixed term contract in the last 11 months I have been with them… Not only this makes me sick about how they parasites can screw me up and my inability to walk away being tied up in a 24 month contract. Ofcom… my back.

Guest
david murray says:
12 April 2014

Recently joined o2,signed a two year contract thinking it was fixed,BEFORE even had the first online bill RECEIVED A LETTER THROUGH THE POST WITH A PRICE RISE!Ofcom must do something about this what looks like a commercial practice to lure you in and then apply an immediate price rise.A very one sided contract which you can’t get out of,but they can alter as and when they want.Please beware ALL NETWORKS ARE DOING THIS.

Guest
waveylines says:
14 April 2014

Yes all the mobile phone companies are doing this_ I too have had a letter through from EE for the other mobile phone contract that still has 3 months to go with a grid of the price hikes -they can’t even be bothered to specify what the actual price hike is -I am supposed to deduce it from the grid! Cheeky is not the word. I have rang them to complain -they told me they are deciding who has to pay on a case by case basis. I said it is well known that mobile phone companies build in their prices to the period you have contract with them this is why you usually find that when you come to renew your contract it is always more money -so how ridiculous that they can offer you a deal which you are tied into but now can hike the price up according toe RTI for the year -absolute rip off! As you can’t leave!
By the way O2 dropped the charge for me for the whole two year period of my contract as they had failed to inform me at the point of contract…..so it’s worth contesting still! good luck!

Guest
mick says:
21 April 2014

I am still incensed and after complaining to 02 they were not the slightest bit interested,when my contract expires I will be leaving.

Guest
Daniel Rhodes says:
8 May 2014

EE relied on the following clause to increase my charges: ‘We can increase any Price Plan Charge. We will give You Written Notice 30 days before We do so…’. This is unlawful under Schedule 2(1)(l) of the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations 1999, under which terms are unfair if they ‘have the object or effect of … allowing a … supplier of services to increase their price without in both cases giving the consumer the corresponding right to cancel the contract if the final price is too high in relation to the price agreed when the contract was concluded.’ The RPI exception in Schedule 2(2)(d) of the Regulations is not applicable in this case, since it requires that ‘the method by which prices vary [must be] explicitly described.’ This is definitely not the case in many of the EE contracts, including mine, so they are unlawfully relying on that contract term. As a result, Article 20(2) of Directive 2002/22/EC (Universal Service Directive), applies and EE ‘subscribers have a right to withdraw from their contract without penalty upon notice of modification to the contractual conditions proposed by the undertakings providing electronic communications networks and/or services.’ Have I missed something here? This is a bit succinct, but I quote the relevant legislation in full in the letters I sent to EE terminating my contract. If I have missed something I’d appreciate it if anyone could let me know. If not, let me know and I’ll happily post the letters I’ve sent to EE on this matter on this or another site so other people can use them.