/ Shopping

Our survey says – self-service checkouts suck

Shopper carrying supermarket basket

Self-service checkouts are a regular feature in our supermarkets, but it’s been claimed that they haven’t cut queuing times. Whether this is true or not, your votes show that more of you loathe than love them.

A small increase waiting times at staffed checkouts in Tesco and Sainsbury’s have been cited as proof that self-service checkouts don’t work.

The timings were provided by The Grocer, but even they weren’t convinced that these waiting times (up by around 10 seconds) actually refuted the value of self-service.

For a start, the same report showed that waiting times in Asda and Morrisons had in fact dropped in the past two years. Secondly, when taking self-service checkouts into consideration, waiting times overall have dropped in most supermarkets.

But then there’s the opinion that more self-service checkouts mean less staff – an ugly detail that supermarkets have tried to deny. There’ll always be questions over whether scanning shopping ourselves is for our benefit or for the benefit of the supermarkets’ bottom line.

Whatever the truth, it looks like we’ll have no choice – around 15,000 of these ‘unexpected item’ scanners are expected to be working in our country’s supermarkets by next year.

Most of us hate self-service checkouts

And it looks like this roll-out won’t please most shoppers – six in ten of you said that you hated self-service checkouts in our poll of over a thousand people. Of those cynics, two in five said they were worse than unsmiling checkout assistants, with a quarter finding them difficult to use.

In our comments section others said that the robotic checkouts were unintuitive, with others frustrated by the need for assistance when buying items like alcohol. But they do have their supporters – a third of you said you liked them because they’re speedy and convenient.

Although most disliked self-service checkouts, quite a few of you had a soft spot for Waitrose’s quick-check system, where shoppers scan their shopping as they go. Whether this will catch on in other supermarkets is unknown, especially since the system relies on trust.

In the end, whether you love or loathe self-service checkouts, what’s important is having the choice of using a staffed till. Personally, I’m waiting for the day when I can load my shopping trolley and just walk out of the supermarket as it’s all automatically scanned and charged to my card. Now that’s convenience.

You can read my original post on self-service checkouts, complete with poll results, here.

Comments
Guest

I love self-service checkouts. I don’t have to deal with talking to a cashier, I can do everything at my own pace, and best of all I can keep my headphones blaring while I pay for my shopping.

There’s always the “needing assistance” thing, but honestly it’s a minor inconvenience, really. I don’t find them difficult to use at all, either- it’s just scanning stuff and putting it on the platform.

Guest
Tom H says:
25 August 2010

I only use self service checkout at the supermarket. This way I know that the right amount of items are being scanned and can keep an eye on the prices. I also like bagging my own groceries ( frozen food in one bag , meats in another , dairy in another , etc) At least once a week, an item scans the wrong price and the market has to give me the item for free.

Guest

Tom’s point is a good one, but by law (unless it has changed since I last worked in retail) the till must have a customer facing display so you should be able to keep a clear eye on prices at a manned till too. Bag packing is usually up to the customer anyway in the shops I know – only Sainsbury’s seem to be over enthusiastic about packing for you, and even they don’t actually do it without asking, but I do agree that packing your own bags is preferable.

However, I’m afraid that I am absolutely against self service tills for the following three reasons:
1) for customers with a sight impairment, who still have cards that you sign for rather than use a PIN, the self service tills can’t cope: as soon as you insert your card the machine starts to sound an alarm and call for an assistant. This would be OK except that assistants in so many shops these days have never been trained to deal with signature cards and so whether a manned or self service checkout is in use, the assistant usually comes along and doesn’t know what to do, then has to fetch someone else and so on, meanwhile the sight-impaired customer is embarrassed and annoyed and the queue behind them gets ever more full of irritable and sometimes abusive people.
2) in my experience (especially in B&Q) the security scale cannot cope with lightweight items and no matter how hard you slam down (or how gently you place) an item on the scale, if it is not heavy enough the machine won’t allow you to scan the rest of your shopping because it thinks that you have broken the rules and bagged something directly. Again, this results in an assistant being called and often they cannot make the till behave properly either and again a queue forms.
3) It is morally reprehensible that we should be making checkout staff redundant in order to maximise the profits of the shops, and no matter which way you look at it or how much the shops deny it, this is what is happening.

Guest
Graham Forecast says:
26 August 2010

you could also add that, in Tesco at least, its impossible to use your own bags, unless you are prepared to scan everything, placing it directly on the security scale, then bagging it after you have paid.

Guest

well, let’s start with banning machines and computers in every aspect of modern life that have led to people losing their jobs since, ooh, the Industrial Revolution? Yes, down with this sort of thing.

Guest

If you have a large shop with/without kids self service is out and takes longer as you cant scan, pack and load the trolley at the same time. For 1 basket its easy and for 1 item in B&Q or any where else for that matter its a godsend.

My only comment would be is where they are set out and the number they have. Tescos where I have shopped are all in one place and there arent enough so you have to queue – its a v large superstore so there should be more. Sainsbury’s have more and split them into two groups and spread them apart – same sized store.

I can also appreciate DD’s comment and would add that the whole process and weighing veg etc for some might also cause problems

Guest
Emily says:
26 August 2010

I’m happy to use either self-service or manned checkouts. What I want to know is why, when I’m in the self-service line, does the line for self-service checkouts always take longer than the line for manned checkouts, but when I’m in the manned line, it takes longer than the line for self-service checkouts? Sometimes I feel the universe would like me to spend half my life in line at Sainsbury’s.

Guest

Emily, there is a well-known theory for this. I think eminent scientists have called it Sod’s Law!

Guest

I like using the self checkouts and agree that waiting times in Asda have decreased as they have recently added more self checkout tills. When I spoke to my 80 year old mother about the tills she said she no longer goes to Asda for a few items as she doesn’t know how to use them and doesn’t want to know how to use them and as there are no manned quick tills this means she has to use another supermarket which is further from home and more expensive.