/ Home & Energy

Why does my energy company hold onto my money?

The other day I got a nice surprise when my energy bill arrived in the post, and found I’m in credit by £100! Great, but if I’m in so much credit, why is my money sitting in my energy company’s bank account?

I’m not the only person asking this question. Which?’s executive director, Richard Lloyd, is on Radio 5 Live all week talking about consumer rights, and on Monday a listener raised this precise issue.

Give me my money back!

So what can we do about it? Well I thought that one option would be to phone up the energy company in question and ask them to give it back. It wasn’t that easy.

They explained that the £100 I had in credit was only partly refundable because, although my gas bill was up to date, I hadn’t been billed for electricity since April. Confused? I am.

So I paid £66 on my last bill, submitted two meter readings shortly afterwards and got a statement saying I’m over £100 in credit. Wouldn’t this suggest that I paid too much on my last bill and that, not only should I get a refund, but they should also adjust my direct debit?

Well no, not according to Michael, the customer service rep who explained four times why this wouldn’t happen. I still don’t understand the reasoning. Perhaps it will all become clear when I over pay again in October?

Why’s it so complicated?

But should we really have to go to so much hassle? A colleague of mine at Which? was also in credit a few months back and the energy company simply paid back the amount without him even having to pick up the phone.

I accept that when paying by monthly direct debit, there needs to be a certain amount of flexibility – since you’re likely to be in credit after the warm summer months and in debit after a cold winter. These payments should balance out in the end. And I also accept that it’s our responsibility to make sure our meter readings are correct, by informing our energy provider every three months.

But it looks like energy companies have far too much leeway to arbitrarily decide what their policy is when our accounts are in credit. For instance, British Gas automatically refunds you when your £200 in credit, compared to E.ON which does so when you’re only in £5 credit.

At the end of the day, most of these companies will simply return the money if you ask for it. But should we have to when it’s our money they’re holding on to? After all, what would you prefer; money in your bank account earning you interest, or in your energy companies’ coffers?

Charlie says:
20 July 2014

I recently, a couple of months ago, switched away from First Utility. I informed them before I switched, via their website, and asked them to refund the nearly £200 pound I was in credit.
Did I get my money back? No, in fact they continued to bill me for a further 6 weeks when I was nolonger their customer!

I phoned them to ask what was going on and why they had not refunded MY money. I was unbelievably told that they could not refund the money straight away due to a fault with their system. Presumably the same problem they had in June 2013 when other customers were complaining that they didn’t get their money for 3 months.

It is surely not acceptable that First Utility appears to have a policy of keeping money from their customers for a number of months after they have left. To me this can only be so that they can earn interest on the money that they keep in their corporate bank account.

They are not doing themselves any favours by adopting this policy as I, and I sure other ex-customers, will be letting everyone know what they do.

Colin G says:
28 July 2014

I am having the same problem having switched away from First Utility in April, who has the cheek to debit me another £125 more than a month after I switched. They have now at last agreed to pay the £238 they owe me, but have said it could take another 15 working days. Unacceptable, and I won’t be going back to them.

Taking a wider view, this surely is one more downside of a market where all the ‘competition’ comes from small, understaffed billing companies, not real competition between actual energy suppliers.


If you tell them you will contact the national press ,The bbcs Money Box program and write about them on facebook you might get some action .I did and they soon got moving

Frusterated says:
24 February 2015

I left First Utility in March. It took 3 months and 3phone calls to recover my overpayment. However 7 months after I left they phoned to say I owed them just under £100. The caller was unable to tell me why this was the case, but that I needed to pay the money by card over the phone immediately. Naturally I refused and requested an explanation by letter. In response I received an e-mail stating I owed this money but no reason or explanation was given, followed about 2weeks later by a very threatening e-mail stating the steps they would follow if I didn’t pay up. I wrote to them stating that as far as I’m concerned I do not owe them any money and they never replied to me. However I have now received a leaflet from a debt collector stating I owe this money. The leaflet shows a phone no but no address. I have no intension of contacting them. Has anyone else been treated like this by First Utility??


I have been waiting 7 months for my £300 of extra energy moved house and gave them my readings and photos of both my meters rang them 10 times on average takes 45 min to get through told it is all sorted but then nothing is done .

callum says:
25 October 2016

Yep, First utility have done the exact same thing to me, charged me £300 over just a 6 week billing period after I left a rented property. contacted me 3 years later! im taking it to the ombudsman.

Linda Roshdy says:
10 October 2017

I am going through exactly the same problem with Extra Energy they owe me £248 but I just cant get my money.

john wiggins says:
20 July 2014

whatever you do stay away from this company full of excuses but very little action, left after very poor service no bills for 7 months then left for weeks waiting for my £200+credit refund, very bad company.

derek shawcross says:
22 July 2014

i have been fighting british gas now for eight years yes eight year for money they owe me witch is £3066,33p they tell me it will go in my bank but never does now after eight years of phone calls and hundreds of pounds later i,m still not got it, i told them i won,t interest on it as they would if it was me,i have a letter of them admitting they owe me but getting it well yes i am still waiting, the phone calls can last up to one hour plus times that by eight years it,s a lot of my time and money,

Vince says:
24 July 2014

I am having similar problems with being billed for a meter that doesn’t exist by Spark Energy. @Derek Shawcross, go to the ombudsman ASAP, that is far too much money to me missing!

Crissy says:
7 July 2016

I changed from british gas last year to first utility im both metersits a prepayment meter im paying an absolute fortune and i used to get an extra £130 in the winter as my entitlement with me being on such a low income i have to also pay £13 a week = extra for my box room as i am in a 3 bedroom house me and my son but my daughter was living with us too when first moved here and i have 2 grandkids who sleep over and because i wont downsize i have to pay this including £12 council tax out of the small amount of benefits i recieve, if the room was a foot smaller i wouldnt have to pay redicilous!
Cannot even afford to go shopping after direct debits any advice would be great.


Crissy , it depends on where you look as to the position of First Utility . Which gives it an average+ , TP likes it but there are many that dont . It isnt the cheapest or best value for energy I would leave it and go elsewhere but you are hampered with prepayment meters while other energy bundles using DD are cheaper . As you know your council tax relates to house size and the government changed the charges for those with extra rooms , as in -live by yourself in a large house or extra rooms , benefit reduction 14 % of eligible rent for 1 spare bedroom and 25 % for 2 or more. Also your savings come into it if over £6000 and if children under 10 then expected to share bedroom . It depends also where you live as to the council tax . The winter allowance is for heating and depends on income and whether you are an OAP and also whether a cold weather payment is triggered. There is a lot more but it starts getting personal.

Libby says:
26 February 2017

[This comment has been removed as it could be considered rude/offensive, which breaches our Community Guidelines https://conversation.which.co.uk/commenting-guidelines/ Thanks, mods.]