/ Health

Would you use home genetic tests?

Hand holding test tube with DNA

We’re being offered the chance to take charge of our health with DNA tests that claim to work out the probability of developing certain diseases. Are they a valuable insight into our future health, or a dangerous folly?

Direct to consumer genetic testing is a service that uses a bit of your bodily fluid (usually saliva) to read your DNA code.

The company offering the service then looks for specific patterns in your DNA that relate to the probability of developing certain diseases.

The crystal ball of genetic tests

In a way, this sounds both exciting and useful. What can my genes tell me about my future? Will this knowledge help me alter my lifestyle to stop the development of a disease in the future?

For example, one company offers a screening test to see if you’re likely to develop diabetes. Surely it’d be good to know this in advance, as you could then change your diet and work on the bulge in a bid to prevent it?

Well, no. Closer inspection reveals that the link between different versions of genes and the probability of developing a given disease are not very clear at all. In July the US government investigated these tests and found conflicting results.

For instance, one researcher was told that he had a below average, average, and above average chance of developing prostate cancer by different companies looking at the same DNA.

Home genetic tests a dangerous rip-off

But perhaps these tests are just a bit of fun and I’m taking them far too seriously. I would say not. At between £100 and £1,000 a pop, these tests would be an expensive bit of fun.

Combine this high price tag with the tests’ marketing, this expensive bit of fun also becomes a dangerous rip-off. The veneer of validity conjured up by the lab coats can mislead consumers into believing that the tests will tell them something useful about their future health.

The fact that these tests are offered direct to consumers, often via the internet, introduces another level of concern. How does a firm that offers tests over the web ensure that consumers are fully informed of the results’ implications? And more importantly that the sample is from the person who has sent it in?

Go to the NHS instead

For these reasons I think that genetic tests that claim to screen individuals for serious diseases like cancer and diabetes shouldn’t be offered direct to consumers. If you’re concerned about these, the NHS can offer genetic tests. These are subject to tough assessments that ensure they provide useful results, and are only offered by trained medical professionals with the provision of counselling.

Tests offered outside of this setting are in danger of causing unnecessary concern or even unwarranted reassurances that could have a serious impact on a patient’s health. It could even result in healthy people flooding the NHS for reassurance.

Would you use home genetic tests?

No, I'll stick to professional medical advice (58%, 90 Votes)

I don't know, they sound expensive (24%, 37 Votes)

Yes, the results could prompt me to look after my health (18%, 27 Votes)

Total Voters: 154

Loading ... Loading ...
ahmed says:
8 October 2010

it has always been the case that whenever a new science comes along, people are apprehensive if not resistant to it. we would not have advanced, had it not been for the first “barbaric” surgery, without the first heart transplant. imagine that world, not so long ago, how people would have reacted to a surgeon saying he would open up a person and take his heart out, and replace it with some metalic and plastic bits.Now, News are a 24 hours event, an exclusive waiting to happen, so people react with their instinct, ie, the status quo, what they know, what they feel comfortable with. Sure, there will be the mishaps, the odd chernobyl, they always happen, that’s the nature of things. you won’t run untill you walk, stumble, fall, stand up again, and so on. i personally we should encourage it, albeit with strict guidelines, as if it falls in the hands of a banker, or a venture capitalist, it can be “pushed” to happen before due time

I wouldn’t use them at home – but all in favour in doctor’s surgeries

Sophie Gilbert says:
12 October 2010

A home genetic test will tell you something, but a), you may not be able to interpret what it tells you correctly if you aren’t trained to do so (eg if you aren’t a doctor yourself); and b), it won’t take into account anything that’s happened to you since birth, what sort of life you’ve had, diet, bad luck (if you catch some types of viruses) or otherwise, and so on and so forth.