/ Food & Drink, Shopping

Is your food lighter than it claims?

Tin with tape measure

Are the grams on the supermarket products you buy accurate? Our snapshot investigation of 467 supermarket products found that some weighed significantly less…

In 2012 we discovered that 80% of the smoked salmon packs we’d measured were underweight. We wanted to broaden our test for 2015, so we asked food fraud expert Professor Chris Elliot to help us investigate underweight food in supermarkets.

His researchers at Queen’s University Belfast weighed 467 food products bought from supermarkets in Northern Ireland and found that 73 were below the recognised margin of error (this ranges from 4.5g on a product weighing 50g or 15g for a 1kg product).

Products that we found weighed less

Products weighing less than the margin of error:

  • 23 out of 32 tins of Heinz Chunky Veg Big Soup.
  • Six out of eight samples of Tesco Finest smoked salmon.
  • 19 out of 31 Green Giant Niblets Original Sweetcorn contained less than the drained weight stated on packaging.
  • Four out of 32 Del Monte Peach Slices in light syrup. Two were very underweight.
underweight foods

We’d expect a small variation in weight, which the margin of error accounts for, but we were surprised by how many samples were below this.

Enforcement for underweight foods

Trading standards officer Paul Ferris couldn’t comment on our research as it wasn’t carried out by accredited weights and measures professionals, but he did say:

‘Discrepancies may be due to natural desiccation of the product – as stated weight relates to the time of packing – inadequate staff training on packing, or incorrectly using weighing equipment.’

It’s important that manufacturers have effective checks in place to make sure you aren’t getting short-changed. And if products are found to be underweight, it’s important that Trading Standards continues its enforcement to help ensure compliance.

What do you think about underweight food? Are you sometimes suspicious that a product is lighter than it claims? Do you ever go to the lengths of getting the scales out to prove a point?

Comments
Lisa M says:
30 August 2020

Bought a can of stewed steak ( 392g Morrison’s own label). Physically felt light when I went to use it. It weighed 360g (including tin). Is this allowed? A tin of Princes of the same spec weighed 411g (including tin). Do I have any recourse? Kind regards

Hi Lisa – This is probably just a one-off mis-steak in the canning process but you can check by taking accurate scales into the shop or using the ones provided in the greengrocery department and checking other cans.

Morrisons should give you at least an apology and a refund. The rules that apply can be found in an earlier post I made: https://conversation.which.co.uk/food-drink/underweight-supermarket-food-cans-tins-weight-grams/#comment-1471729

Lisa M says:
30 August 2020

Many thanks for your time and advice😊

Lisa – I don’t know whether it is still their policy but Morrisons used to replace the product as well as give a full refund if there was some thing wrong with it. It’s worth asking.

I remember when Tesco did this but it was a long time ago.