/ Food & Drink

What’s really in your scampi?

scampi and chips

That Friday Feeling is in the air – and with it a craving for a big plate of fish and chips. But if you’re more of a scampi sort, can you really be sure about what it’s made of?

Up and down the country tonight battered hunks of cod will be spilling off the edge of plates in pubs, vinegar will be stinging the air outside fish and chip shops, and ovens will be steaming up with breaded fillets.

Some of you may even be opting for scampi – after all, it’s a delicious alternative to fish. I personally love it, but I never thought about how breaded scampi is made until I received a letter from a reader asking what exactly a wholetail scampi is.

First off, I learnt you can make your dinner sound a lot more exotic by referring to it as Norway lobster, Dublin Bay Prawn, or langoustine. They’re all the same species: Nephrops norvegicus.

What is wholetail scampi?

According to a code of practice that manufacturers have to stick to, wholetail scampi, or whole scampi, can actually be made of three wholetail pieces.

The three pieces must be placed beside or on top of each other, before being coated in breadcrumbs.

This doesn’t necessarily mean the scampi is of lower quality – it’s simply prepared this way due to the difficulty in keeping a wholetail intact, as automatic peeling can break it up into smaller pieces.

Peering closely at the back of a frozen pack of wholetail scampi might reveal that it’s ‘made from more than one scampi’ or ‘wholetail scampi ingredients’.

Scampi ingredients – what to buy?

If you want scampi that is made from one sole piece of wholetail, look for ‘single wholetail scampi’, which has been hand-peeled to prevent breakage. Bear in mind that this will probably be more expensive.

‘Formed scampi’ is also pretty common in the freezer aisle, and it consists of pieces of scampi coated together, and can also be referred to as ‘scampi pieces’.

You shouldn’t find minced scampi in packs of coated scampi unless explicitly labelled as such, as this goes against the code of practice.

Are you a scampi fan, and do you buy a specific type? Would you be willing to shell out more for single wholetail scampi and will you be paying closer attention to your scampi ingredients from now on?


My preference is to go for the fish & chips and the worst that might happen is cod instead of haddock. 🐟

Slightly off-topic, but still worth sharing – my mother apparently prefers haddock, so has always insisted on haddock and chips from the fish and chip shop. However, my dad has always ordered cod for my mother (haddock is usually more expensive) and asked the fish and chip shop to write a big ‘H’ on the wrapper!

I think she knows 🙂

We also (mrs r and I) prefer haddock which is not really any more expensive here. An advantage also is that it is almost always cooked to order, so it has not been standing in the hot cabinet for an unknown length of time – does the batter no good.

Back to scampi. It is a regular favourite with decent chips and tartar sauce. We never buy reformed scampi – or chicken for that matter. We buy ours from M&S, and there is a generous amount of meat in the batter. A couple of weeks ago we had scampi and chips at a pub, and the scampi occupied very little of the meal, most was batter.

Fish is always cooked to order round here and the skin is removed, as is normal in Scottish fish & chip shops. I don’t know if they sell scampi, but as Siobhan has pointed out in her introduction, there is the possibility of not getting what you expect.

I don’t own a deep-fat frier and my chip pan has only ever been used for soup. I decided to visit my old local pub this evening and will probably go for the fish & chips – but might look at scampi.

This comment was removed at the request of the user

Explains the obesity levels in the USA, duncan Why some are obsessed with eating huge portions that do them no good I really do not know. A feature of an over-affluent society perhaps. Having said that, our haddock are always large, as are portions of chips. One large haddock and chips would feed both of us adequately ( perhaps a small pudding to follow 🙂 ).

If, when in the USA, you choose your restaurants carefully, you’ll get sensibly sized portions – and some really nice steaks too 🙂 🙂 🙂

That works in the UK too, but there is no doubt that large portions are a big selling point. That’s not a problem for those who eat out infrequently but eating scampi & chips etc. every day is best avoided.

jdman says:
4 August 2017

[Sorry, your comment has been removed for being offensive and off-topic. Please ensure your comments align with our Community Guidelines. Thanks, mods]

We quite enjoy scampi from time to time but prefer something more delicate than chips in the potato department.

Do you know what many foods really consist of ,are they what they say they are ? But do you care ?

This comment was removed at the request of the user

Seems to be a case of you get what you pay for. Anyone else remember the time when scampi wasn’t scampi at all, but pieces of cheap monk fish? These days monk fish is anything but cheap!

wisky2234 says:
1 July 2017

I really like the occasional meal of good quality Scampi, and Cod or Haddock and chips. But having lived in Grimsby I can honestly say that no fish, Cod or Haddock from any fish and chip shop in Hereford comes close to the size, quality and taste found in Grimsby’s chippies. For a real treat, when available, I really don’t think you can beat a delicious plate of Whitebait. Also having also lived in Elgin, Scotland, a real Black Pudding supper takes some beating. OK now I really do feel hungry!

I’m with you on the Whitebait, Wisky, with sauté potatoes for preference.

I am highly allergic to fish (I go into anaphylactic shock) but I can eat shellfish with no problems. Re. the comments from jo’s Mum about monkfish being substituted for scampi; some years ago I was dining with friends at a big hotel near Heathrow and ordered the Scampi. Unfortunately, the chef had decided to pad out the scampi with monkfish to cut costs. I had to be carried from the dining room and taken to a room to be treated by a doctor. Generous compensation was paid. More recently, last Xmas I bought from Tesco a pack of Chinese Party nibbles including Prawn toasts of which I am very fond. getting them out of the fridge I happened to look at the list of ingredients to find that the prawn toasts contained 23% white fish and only 8% scampi tails. I should have taken the matter up with Trading Standards but being very close to the holiday did not bother. What is the legal situation?
Incidentally, I now read the ingredients list on all shellfish products I buy.

This comment was removed at the request of the user

Cliff wilson says:
2 July 2017

Oh dear… Typical Which. . This could have been a good article exposing the “scampi scammers” but instead it became a V poorly written obvious piece about frozen “scampi”. This despite starting off as a piece on fish and chip shop food. Try again. Most “scampi” out there isn’t – its simply morsels of “white fish” and a total consumer rip-off…

This comment was removed at the request of the user